In a significant development, the leader of a breakaway Amish sect, Sam Mullet Sr., was sentenced to 15 years in prison on Friday for his involvement in the infamous beard and hair-cutting attacks on fellow Amish individuals. The attacks, which took place in 2011, involved 16 members of his extended family and were carried out on Amish community members with whom they had religious differences. This article delves into the details of the case, the sentencing, and the impact it has had on the Amish community.

The Amish Beard-Cutting Case

The focus of the trial revolved around Sam Mullet Sr., who was the leader of a breakaway Amish group based in Bergholz, Ohio. The community, situated about 100 miles southeast of Cleveland near the West Virginia border, consisted of approximately 20 Amish families residing on Mullet’s 880-acre farm.

The attacks, considered hate crimes by the government, targeted nine victims and took place between September and November 2011. The attackers, led by Mullet’s sons, forcefully cut off beards and hair, causing significant distress to the victims. For the Amish, hair and beards hold immense religious symbolism, making these attacks deeply unsettling for the community.

The Sentencing and Its Consequences

During the sentencing, U.S. District Judge Dan Aaron Polster expressed his concerns about Mullet’s behavior, deeming him a danger to the community. Consequently, he sentenced Mullet to 15 years in federal prison, the longest and harshest sentence among the convicted individuals.

Mullet’s sons, who were also involved in the attacks, requested to serve their father’s sentence. However, the judge handed them sentences ranging from five to seven years. Other convicted individuals received varying prison terms, from as little as a year and a day to seven years.

The impact of the case extended beyond the courtroom, affecting the Amish community in multiple ways. While some members of the community viewed the convicted individuals as victims of Sam Mullet’s manipulations, others believed that the attacks were a result of a deep-rooted family feud. The trial highlighted the delicate balance between religious freedom and the criminality of hate crimes.

Understanding Amish Culture and Symbols

Hair and beards hold significant religious and cultural meaning for the Amish. For married men, growing a beard symbolizes their marital status and adherence to traditional values. Similarly, women’s hair is considered a sign of modesty and adherence to their beliefs. The government’s portrayal of the attacks as hate crimes emphasized the importance of religious freedom and cultural practices within the Amish community.


The sentencing of Sam Mullet Sr. and his family members in the Amish beard-cutting case marks a pivotal moment in the history of the Amish community. As the community grapples with the aftermath of the attacks and the legal proceedings, it also serves as a reminder of the delicate balance between religious freedom and the criminality of hate crimes. The case sheds light on the significance of cultural symbols and practices within the Amish culture and raises essential discussions about the preservation of religious liberties in the United States.